banquo's movie Reviews on Newgrounds

[Out of Order 1]

Well done! When you said that it wasn't as polished as you wished it would be, I wasn't expecting very much. But honestly, that's as polished as anything else I've seen, if not more. The animation was really decent, and the art of clean and stylish. My only problem with the piece was the sound. The voices weren't as clear as I thought they should be, and I found that some of the line phrasing spoken by the characters was kind of awkward.
Otherwise, good job! As mostly a viewer, you inspire me to get into animation.

kmau responds:

With polished I actually meant things like less symbol manip and more frame by frame, or better backgrounds. Imagine how the movie would look if all backgrounds had been digitally painted outside of flash! I agree that the sound quality could be better, but overall I think we managed to reach the average voice quality of Newgrounds movies.

[TF 2 - The greedy King]

DId you ever read the story of ehud and the king? It's similar to this one.

Good work, animation was pretty nice to look at. I thought it wasn't as fast paced as I would like, but it was a good use of sound effects.

twinfang responds:

Thanks! ;)
No, don't know.
This story is ispired from book written by me...

[Finding The Boogeyman]

Hey, good job.

Really not a bad animation, I think. The animation could have been a bit more polished in some parts (smoother, angles, etc.), but not a bad effort. I found the story line humorous, but the voices were kind of mumbled near the end, so it got kind of confusing.
Otherwise, good job. loved the irony.

JonHunter responds:

Thanks man, you're one of the few who got the point.
I'm really taking this in, I agree with you completely. Practice makes perfect, amiright?

[SNAPSHOT: Vol 1]

Well done!

This animation is very cool. The character designs are superb, camera shots are good, and the action scenes are very cool. The scene with the gun and the rope was one of the coolest action scenes I've seen.
I only thing I would say is that the use of minimum shading isn't my favorite. You have a good art style, but i personally prefer more shading in the characters. \i find without the shading, there is a tendency for the animation to look amateur. Thats just me though.

QuasimodoxArt responds:

Thanks!

I agree with your opinion, it would looks much better with additional shading, but instead, I spent my time and focus on drawing enough frames for more smooth animation... It's kind of quality vs quantity... you know.

[Turn That Frown]

Haha

I didn't really laugh that much, but it was kinda cute. I liked it anyways.

jabzinaut responds:

thanks dude! im glad it was cute hah but thanks for watching!

[This and That Shorts 3]

donkeys...

Pretty decent. I saw a poster like this once, where two donkeys were each trying to get at their own food, but there was a rope keeping them together, away from the food (just like in the video). But in the poster, the donkeys went to one side, shared what was there, and then went to the other and shared what was there. It was nice to know you resolved the animation differently.

Kreid responds:

That's the exact poster I based this toon on haha